Bob Dole leads the fight for Ike
WASHINGTON — Most Saturday mornings, former Kansas senator Bob Dole greets fellow veterans at the southern entrance of the National World War II Memorial, shaking hands and posing for photos with a steady stream of visitors.
One recent Saturday, between asking the vets where they’re from, where they served and how old they are (“I’m 93,” boasted Bill Hovestadt. “I’m going to be 92 on Wednesday,” Dole replied.), the former Republican presidential candidate was lobbying for support of the beleaguered National Eisenhower Memorial.
When tour buses carrying veterans from San Antonio and Austin pulled to the curb, volunteers helped the elderly men and women into wheelchairs and pushed them into the World War II Memorial. As the veterans passed, young uniformed soldiers, tourists pushing strollers and volunteers stood in the rain to cheer and applaud. Many called out, “Thank you for your service.”
At the center was Dole, who worked the crowd like a candidate on a campaign trail. He led the effort to raise more than $170 million for the privately funded WWII memorial that opened in 2004. Now, his mission is to get a memorial built for Dwight D. Eisenhower, under whom Dole served in Italy. He considers Eisenhower, a fellow Kansan, “one of the great Americans.” It’s a view, he believes, shared by many WWII vets.
“It’s been 16 years. We’ve got to get it built,” he told Harold Shockley, 90, about the stalled memorial to the WWII general and 34th president.
“He was our hero,” he said to Delbert Armstrong, 88. It was a statement he repeated to Norm Riggsby, 90; Smokey Brittingham, 89; and John Gumfory, 88.
The Texas veterans represent a handful of the 855,000 men and women still living of the 16 million who served, Dole said. Almost 180,000 WWII vets die each year.
“I want to get it built before all of us are gone,” Dole told Tino Rodriguez, 95, who signed Dole’s petition seeking support for the $142 million project.
It will take all of Dole’s political skill to succeed. Authorized by Congress in 1999, the Eisenhower Memorial slogged through the federal regulatory process. This month, famed architect Frank Gehry’s modified design received final approval from the National Capital Planning Commission, weeks after another federal agency, the U.S. Commission of Fine Arts, gave its final approval.
But even those milestones were tarnished. Eisenhower’s family, led by granddaughter Susan Eisenhower, has never embraced the design. As a result, two congressional appropriations committees declined to provide any of the $68 million that the Eisenhower Memorial Commission sought for construction for 2016. By law, construction can’t begin until full funding is in hand.
“It simply defies logic and decency to design and build a memorial to Dwight Eisenhower without obtaining the approval of the Eisenhower family,” Rep. Ken Calvert (R-Calif.), chairman of the appropriations subcommittee with jurisdiction over the project, told The Washington Post last month.
Critics such as the National Civic Art Society and Right by Ike group have charged that the commission has a stubborn desire to create a modern memorial. Supporters say the opposition, while vocal, is only a small group fueled by a desire to defeat Gehry.
Dole isn’t interested in blame.
“I don’t want to fault anybody. I just want to get it built,” he said from his office at the law firm of Alston & Bird, where he is special counsel. “I respect the family, but I also respect the veterans who served under Ike. We ought to have some say in it.”
A long and messy road
The road to building a memorial in the nation’s capital is often long and messy, and the Eisenhower project is no exception. It took 42 years and several design competitions to complete the memorial for Franklin D. Roosevelt, while the WWII memorial needed 11 years to finish.
The Eisenhower commission spent the first six years securing the four-acre site along Independence Avenue, a block from the Mall, and three more years to select Gehry through the General Services Administration’s Design Excellence Program, a choice that continues to plague the commission. Unlike other competitions, such as the Vietnam Veterans Memorial, the Eisenhower contest sought designers, not specific designs.
The past five years have been consumed by debate over Gehry’s vision. Originally, it featured three stainless-steel tapestries, bas-relief sculptures and a statue of a young Ike gazing into his future. The Eisenhower grandchildren have criticized it as too romantic and complained that it did not do justice to their grandfather’s global achievements.
Commission officials said they have listened to the family’s concerns. Gehry’s original plan has been modified to remove two stainless-steel tapestries that helped to frame the park’s perimeter. There is still a statue of a youthful Ike, but the memorial core now features one bronze sculpture depicting Eisenhower as the supreme Allied commander during the war, and another bronze statue showing him as the president.
The family has not made any public statements about the most recent design, although in a letter to the commission last September, family members said they favored a “simpler design” or a new design competition.
Susan Eisenhower said in an e-mail that she sympathizes with Dole and other veterans who want to see the memorial built.
“My family and countless other people are working very hard to make this happen, and to assure that the memorial reflects the consequential nature of Eisenhower’s service to this country — in war and peace,” she said.
Although the Eisenhowers and other critics have lost the design battle, the skirmish continues over funding. The groups that railed against Gehry’s design are focusing their arguments on the flawed selection process and the commission’s inefficient operations. The end game remains the same: prevent the current design from being built.
It seems to be working. The House and Senate appropriations bills provide no construction funds, notes Justin Shubow, president of the National Civic Art Society and a relentless critic.
“The House [budget] language calls for a reset and to fire the staff,” Shubow said.
The NCAS has about 100 members and had an operating budget of $59,000 in 2014. Shubow says the organization hosts lectures about civic architecture. The tax filings, however, show 94 percent of last year’s program funding was used to “educate the public and decision makers on issues related to the process and design” of the memorial.
The largest donation to the NCAS in 2014 was $33,000 from Richard Driehaus, a Chicago philanthropist who promotes classical art and architecture. Shubow said Driehaus hasn’t donated any money to NCAS this year, but Driehaus is a member and funder of Right by Ike, the group that pays its spokesman Sam Roche and D.C. lobbying firm ASGK Public Strategies to block the memorial.
Driehaus did not return a message left at his Chicago foundation, but in March he told an architectural magazine that he is funding the opposition because, “architecturally, it doesn’t speak to me. We want something more representational.”
Meanwhile, the commission has ramped up its fundraising and public relations efforts. Two weeks ago, it announced its largest gift to date, a $1 million donation from the government of Taiwan. Total donations are at $1.5 million, officials said. It also announced journalist and “The Greatest Generation” author Tom Brokaw has joined its advisory board. Brokaw said he will not be involved in the fundraising, but he joined “as a favor to Bob Dole.”
“I’m just hopeful this can be resolved amicably and the project can go forward, because Eisenhower deserves his permanent place on the Mall while WWII vets are still around to pay homage,” Brokaw said.
Commission officials also have changed their tactics with Congress. They are asking lawmakers for $24 million in the 2016 budget and permission to complete the project in stages. So far, it has received $46 million in federal funding.
Dole is making calls on their behalf, but he is losing patience. The memorial will take three years to build, he said, and thousands of vets will die each year.
“If we can’t satisfy the family and other naysayers, we should forget about Congress and raise the money privately,” he said. “If they get it started this year, I’m planning to be at the dedication, God willing. But I want some other guys with me.”